Categories > Guides and Tips

Comparing a Family Condo vs. HDB Flat in Singapore Which is better to live in

Comparing a Family Condo vs. HDB Flat in Singapore: Which is better to live in?

Choosing the right home isn’t just about four walls and a roof; it’s about your lifestyle, your family’s well-being, and your financial future.

So, whether you’re a native Singaporean weighing your options or someone considering moving to this vibrant city, I’ve got your back!

I’ve spent years navigating the intricate world of housing options in Singapore. I’ve studied property listings, attended countless viewings, and signed those dotted lines, all in the quest for the perfect family nest.

We’ll discuss the luxurious amenities and facilities that come with the condo and HDB flat living and the allure of spacious, modern designs.

But we’ll also talk about the potential financial pitfalls, like higher purchase costs and the risks of the property market, that come with choosing where you’ll live.

Family Condos in Singapore

Family Condos in Singapore

Family condos come in different sizes. They can be compact units perfect for couples or spacious abodes accommodating an extended family.

You can own a studio unit, a semi-furnished, or a fully furnished condo complete with appliances and home accessories.

Inside these towers, you’ll find a treasure trove of amenities and facilities, like a playground for the whole family, swimming pools, gyms, playgrounds, and even BBQ pits for family gatherings.

Condos cater to all sorts. This housing type can adapt to your lifestyle and family size. 

And that’s just one of the many reasons family condos are so popular in Singapore.

Pros of Living in a Family Condo in Singapore

Pros of Living in a Family Condo in Singapore

The perks of condo living can be downright enticing. You can enjoy luxurious amenities and enhanced security, spacious and modern designs, and better resale and rental value.

But there’s more to it than just the surface glamour. It’s about your financial future, too. 

Family condos are promising investments with excellent potential for capital appreciation.

Here are the pros of living in a family condo.

Luxurious Amenities and Facilities

One of the major attractions of living in a family condo in Singapore is the luxurious amenities and facilities available at your doorstep.

Condo living often grants you access to swimming pools, gyms, playgrounds, BBQ pits, and even serene gardens where you can unwind.

These amenities can significantly enhance your quality of life, promoting a healthy and active lifestyle right within your residential community.

For families, these amenities provide excellent options for spending quality time together.

Enhanced Privacy and Security

Enhanced Privacy and Security

Family condos excel in providing privacy and security. With a gated community, access control, and round-the-clock security personnel, you can feel safe and secure in your condo unit.

Moreover, condos often come with security cameras, intercom systems, and even smart home technology that can further enhance your peace of mind.

You won’t have to worry about strangers loitering around, and your family can enjoy a comfortable and secure environment.

Larger Living Spaces and Modern Designs

Larger Living Spaces and Modern Designs

Family condos often boast spacious living areas, and let me tell you, this extra room can make all the difference in your daily life.

And here’s the cherry on top: modern condos have open-concept designs and abundant natural light.

It’s almost like you’re bringing the outdoors in, making your everyday life more pleasant and enjoyable.

Better Resale and Rental Value

Better Resale and Rental Value

In Singapore, renting a family condo can be a wise financial move. People are drawn to the luxurious lifestyle and the convenience that condos offer.

This high demand means you’re more likely to find a tenant quickly if you rent out your unit, ensuring a steady rental income of up to S$8,000 per month, depending on the unit’s size or amenities.

Down the road, if you ever decide on your condo unit, you can sell it from around S$1 million to S$3 million. 

Cons of Living in a Family Condo in Singapore

Cons of Living in a Family Condo in Singapore

While condo living offers a myriad of advantages, it’s not without its drawbacks. 

Opting for a family condo in Singapore may be associated with higher purchase and maintenance costs, the absence of government subsidies, limited access to local markets, and the potential for social isolation.

Let’s explore these disadvantages in detail.

Higher Purchase and Maintenance Costs

Higher Purchase and Maintenance Costs

Condo prices can be steep, which can be a barrier for families on a tight budget, and the costs don’t stop at the initial purchase.

Condo living involves monthly maintenance fees that cover the upkeep of the amenities, security, and common areas. These fees, averaging from S$300 to S$500 per month, can add up and significantly impact your monthly expenses.

Risk of Fluctuating Property Market

Risk of Fluctuating Property Market

While Singapore’s property market is generally stable, it can be influenced by various factors, like market trends, economic conditions, and government policies.

For example, you bought a lovely family condo in a prime location during a booming property market. Prices were soaring, and you felt like you had made a brilliant investment. 

Fast forward a couple of years, and suddenly, the market takes a downturn.

Economic conditions change, and government policies tighten up a bit. Your condo’s value starts to dip. It’s not what you expected, and it can be a downer.

It’s essential to keep an eye on the property market trends and, most importantly, to consider the long-term implications of your investment.

It might mean you need to hold onto your condo for a bit longer, or it could influence your future financial plans.

The key takeaway here is that, like any investment, risks are involved, and being informed and prepared is your best defense against unexpected twists in the property market rollercoaster.

Limited Government Subsidies

Limited Government Subsidies

Other housing types in Singapore enjoy significant financial advantages through government subsidies.

These subsidies are like a helping hand from the government to make housing more affordable for Singaporeans. They reduce the initial purchase cost, ease the burden of monthly payments, and make the dream of home ownership more attainable for many.

But when you’re considering a family condo, you won’t have the luxury of these government subsidies. You’ll be shouldering the full cost of your property, and that’s where the challenge lies.

This lack of government support can be a disadvantage, especially for first-time homebuyers or those with limited financial resources.

You’ll have to dig deeper into your pockets to afford the initial purchase and cope with higher monthly expenses.

Competitive Pricing and Potential Over-Investment

Competitive Pricing and Potential Over-Investment

The allure of family condos can lead to intense competition and bidding wars, which can drive up the prices of these properties.

As a buyer, this can be stressful and might result in over-investment. You might pay more for a condo unit than it’s worth due to the high demand.

Additionally, condos often come with various unit types and sizes, each priced differently. This makes it easy to get carried away and purchase a larger, more expensive unit than you actually need.

Over-investment can strain your finances and may not be a wise financial decision.

Limited Access to Nearby Markets

Limited Access to Nearby Markets

Family condos are often located in prime, central areas, which can be advantageous in many ways.

However, this also means you might have limited access to local markets and hawker centers. These markets offer affordable and delicious food options, making them a favorite among Singaporeans.

Living in a condo might mean you’ll need to travel a bit further to buy groceries or enjoy local delights, which can be a minor inconvenience.

Potential for Social Isolation

Potential for Social Isolation

Living in a family condo often means being surrounded by a diverse group of residents, but it’s worth noting that the nature of condo living can sometimes create a sense of exclusivity.

While you may have the luxury of interacting with people from various walks of life, the design and layout of condo communities can sometimes lead to less spontaneous neighborly encounters.

Don’t get me wrong; it’s not a cold or unfriendly atmosphere. It’s just that condo living tends to be more private, and the interactions may be limited to polite nods in the hallway or brief “hellos” in the elevator.

If you’re someone who thrives on those casual chats with neighbors, spontaneous gatherings, or the comforting familiarity of local hawker centers, you might find the social aspect of condo living a tad different. 

HDB Flats in Singapore

HDB Flats in Singapore

HDB flats are built and managed by the Housing and Development Board, a government agency that provides affordable housing to Singaporean citizens.

HDB flats come in various sizes, from studio apartments to spacious four-room flats, making them suitable for individuals, couples, and families.

Each flat has essential facilities like a kitchen, bathroom, and living area, but larger flats also offer separate bedrooms, providing ample living space.

What’s truly impressive is the meticulous planning that goes into these estates. The Housing and Development Board doesn’t just build homes; it creates complete communities with access to public transportation, healthcare, and recreational areas.

Additionally, residents can enjoy various housing schemes, like Build-To-Order (BTO) and resale flats.

Pros of Living in an HDB Flat in Singapore

Pros of Living in an HDB Flat in Singapore

Living in an HDB flat offers many advantages that make it a compelling choice for many Singaporean residents. It offers a sense of community, modern amenities, and financial stability for families on a tight housing budget.

Let’s explore these pros in detail.

Affordable Housing Options

Affordable Housing Options

HDB flats make the dream to attain a house property quite achievable, even in a city where property prices can be sky-high.

The starting rates for HDB flats can be surprisingly budget-friendly, depending on the location and type of unit you choose.

On average, you can find HDB flats for as low as S$100,000 to S$200,000. This cost is incredibly reasonable, considering the high cost of living in Singapore.

This affordability is a lifeline for many Singaporeans, enabling them to step onto the property ladder without emptying their savings or taking on enormous loans.

Subsidies and Grants for First-Time Buyers

Subsidies and Grants for First-Time Buyers

The Singaporean government is keen on encouraging home ownership. There are several subsidies and grants available for first-time HDB flat buyers.

These include the Enhanced CPF Housing Grant and the Additional Housing Grant, which can substantially reduce the cost of purchasing an HDB flat. 

The Enhanced CPF Housing Grant is designed to help offset the initial costs of buying your HDB flat. The amount you receive depends on your income, and it can make a significant dent in your down payment, making homeownership more affordable.

Meanwhile, the Additional Housing Grant is tailored for low to middle-income families. This grant extends its helping hand further by offering additional financial assistance.

It can seriously reduce the financial burden of purchasing your first HDB flat.

Close-Knit and Diverse Communities

Close-Knit and Diverse Communities

HDB estates are renowned for their tight-knit communities. With neighbors living in close proximity, it’s easy to form connections and build a sense of belonging.

This diversity is a unique feature of HDB estates, as they house residents from various backgrounds and walks of life.

The sense of community and social cohesion is something you will like in this housing option if you want to form special connections.

Proximity to Essential Amenities and Hawker Centers

Proximity to Essential Amenities and Hawker Centers

Singapore is famous for its hawker centers and bustling neighborhoods, and HDB flats are often situated in the heart of these vibrant communities.

You’ll no longer have to travel further just to buy essentials or go on a street food trip. From food courts to supermarkets and healthcare facilities, you’ll find everything you need right at your doorstep.

This convenience enhances the quality of life for HDB flat residents.

Resilience against Market Fluctuations

Resilience against Market Fluctuations

One thing we all worry about when investing in a home is how the property market might fluctuate.

The price of private properties in Singapore can sometimes be affected by various factors such as economic conditions, government policies, and market sentiments.

This can make it a bit nerve-wracking for homeowners who fear their investment might plummet at any moment.

However, when you choose an HDB flat, you get a piece of real estate that tends to stay more stable during market ups and downs.

The government’s role in subsidizing the construction and sale of HDB flats plays a significant part in this stability. It’s like having a safety net that helps protect your investment.

Cons of Living in an HDB Flat in Singapore

Cons of Living in an HDB Flat in Singapore

While HDB flats offer numerous advantages, there are some drawbacks to consider. You may have to settle for a smaller space, noise pollution and privacy issues, and limited customization of your flat.

Here are the disadvantages of living in an HDB flat.

Limited Space and Smaller Unit Sizes

Limited Space and Smaller Unit Sizes

HDB flats, especially the older ones, have limited living space. While they’re expertly designed to maximize every square inch, they might not cater to those who crave more room to spread out.

For families, it might mean some creative thinking regarding storage solutions and furniture choices.

In multi-generation households, these constraints can become even more noticeable. 

Finding separate spaces for family members to enjoy their privacy or finding room for everyone’s belongings can be like piecing together a jigsaw puzzle.

Aging Infrastructure in Some Estates

Aging Infrastructure in Some Estates

While HDB estates are generally well-maintained, older estates may face issues related to aging infrastructure. This can include problems with plumbing, electrical systems, and common areas.

Pro Tip
You should first research the estate you’re considering and be aware of any potential maintenance concerns. 
You should also ask about the estate’s maintenance history and whether any major renovations or upgrades are planned.
This information can help you assess the overall condition of the HDB estate and determine if you encounter any structural or infrastructure issues in the future.

Limited Customization and Design Options

Limited Customization and Design Options

HDB flats have certain restrictions when it comes to significant structural changes, like knocking down walls, expanding rooms, or completely reshaping the space.

The basic layout and structure of the flat are predefined, which means you might not be able to create the exact living space you’ve always envisioned.

You can still make some modifications, like changing the interior decor, rearranging furniture, or even renovating within certain guidelines.

Noise and Privacy Issues in Densely Populated Areas

Noise and Privacy Issues in Densely Populated Areas

HDB estates are often densely populated, leading to noise and privacy concerns.

Most HDB flats have thin walls, and close proximity to neighbors means that you might hear sounds from adjacent units. It’s crucial to consider how well you can tolerate such conditions.

Potential Long Waiting Times for Allocation

Potential Long Waiting Times for Allocation

The demand for HDB flats is pretty high in Singapore. Both locals and expats are keen on owning their space.

The length of your waiting period can vary, depending on two factors.

First, where you want your HDB flat to be located is a biggie. Popular locations tend to have longer queues, as everyone wants a piece of the action.

Second, the type of flat you’re eyeing matters too. Larger units, like three-room or four-room flats, often have more extended waiting lists than smaller ones. 

Factors to Consider When Choosing between a Family Condo and HDB in Singapore

Factors to Consider When Choosing between a Family Condo and HDB in Singapore

It’s time to weigh the pros and cons of the two housing options. Here are the factors that can help you decide between a family condo and an HDB flat in Singapore.

Budget and Affordability

One of the primary considerations when choosing your Singaporean abode is your budget.

The average price for an HDB flat is between S$495,000 and S$532,768. Meanwhile, condo units come with a heftier price tag, ranging from S$1,467,778 to S$1,780,051.

If you have a larger budget and are willing to invest more in your housing, a family condo can offer luxurious amenities and a comfortable living space.

On the other hand, HDB flats are more budget-friendly. Their cost which typically ranges from S$495,000 and S$532,768 can even be further reduced through government subsidies that you may be eligible for. 

Subtracting the minimum HDB cost from the minimum condo cost, you’re looking at savings of around S$972,778 or 65% by going for an HDB flat instead of a condo.

There are various types of HDB flats available, from 2-room flexi to 5-room flats, each catering to different budget brackets.

If you want to save on initial costs, an HDB flat might be the right choice.

Desired Living Space and Customization

Family condos often provide more spacious and customizable living areas. You’ll typically find a range of condo sizes, from compact two-bedroom units to lavish penthouses.

If you value spaciousness and have a specific vision for your living space, a family condo might be more suitable for your needs.

HDB flats, while generally more compact, offer a comfortable and functional living space. They may not provide as much room for customization, but they have certain built-in features and amenities.

If you prefer a more straightforward living environment, an HDB flat could be just what you need.

Community and Lifestyle Preferences

Family condos often have various facilities, such as swimming pools, gyms, and communal gardens, creating a more upscale and communal atmosphere.

If you value these amenities and aspire to live in a vibrant, closely-knit community, a family condo may be more appealing.

HDB flats, on the other hand, offer a more diverse and integrated living environment.

If you appreciate diversity and the sense of living in a culturally rich neighborhood, an HDB flat could be the ideal choice for you.

Long-Term Investment and Resale Goals

When purchasing a property, it’s essential to consider the long-term investment potential and resale value.

Family condos in Singapore have been known to appreciate at a faster rate compared to HDB flats. If you’re looking at your property as a long-term investment, a family condo might offer a more favorable return.

The Housing and Development Board has regulations on selling HDB flats in the open market, which are designed to maintain the affordability of public housing. If you’re planning to upgrade to a condo in the future, owning an HDB flat can still serve as a valuable asset.

Government Subsidies and Grants

Singapore’s government provides various subsidies and grants to make housing more affordable for its citizens. These subsidies are particularly advantageous for HDB flats.

While family condos do not have the same level of government subsidies, some developer discounts or incentives may be available for first-time condo buyers. 

It’s essential to weigh these options carefully and consider your eligibility for housing grants when making your decision.

Maintenance and Monthly Expenses

Another crucial aspect to consider is the ongoing maintenance and monthly expenses associated with your housing choice.

Family condos often come with higher monthly maintenance fees due to the upkeep of the shared facilities and amenities.

The average maintenance fee for condo units varies widely, but it typically ranges from S$300 to S$500 per month, depending on the condo’s facilities and location.

HDB flats generally have lower maintenance fees, making them a more cost-effective option for monthly expenses.

Choosing between a family condo and an HDB flat in Singapore ultimately depends on your budget, lifestyle preferences, long-term goals, and personal circumstances.

Both options have their unique advantages and disadvantages, so it’s crucial to carefully weigh the factors before making your decision. 

You should consult with a real estate expert or financial advisor to ensure that your choice aligns with your goals and financial situation.

With careful consideration, you can find the perfect place to call home for you and your family.